Alan Barnard
Port Angeles, WA

Flight duration is directly related to seat comfort! Or…"sore butt or what?"

    As much as I love my Challenger II, it is not without a few shortcomings, one of which is the seat! In my first Challenger, I had the canvass type which shoved me forward and thus my knees in my chest. If I wanted that, I would own a J3. I should say that I weigh about 250 lbs…not what Dave had in mind when he designed the seat.
    In my second and current Challenger, the seat had been replaced with a solid aluminum plate, exactly like the "new" Challenger seat. With the stock cushion and another 3" cushion under that, and my knees hiked up as guys like me have to sit, my tail bone got sore in the first 20 minutes or so and I was shifting around trying to stave off the need for an interim landing opportunity just to get out and walk around.
    Solution? The seat plate was about 17 inches long or so. I removed it, cut it in half and reinstalled the approximately 8 " section to the front leaving a 8 " to 9" gap between the seat back and the shortened plate, right where the tail bone sits.
    I then drilled a few holes in the back edge of the shortened plate. Lacking any web material or something more professional to make a "sling" I took long wire ties and stretched them from the hole in the shortened seat plate and the cross tube at the rear of the seat, leaving them long enough to slump with my tail bone a couple inches or so. (see photo)
    Now, the shortened plate supports my thighs which has plenty of strength to hold me up under higher "G" maneuvers, and the "sling" made of wire ties, allows my butt to have a nice little pocket to sit in. I added a seat back cushion that I bought from a local auto parts store under the stock seat cushion to slump into the pocket giving my butt plenty of cushion and not pressing the stock cushion against the edge of the shortened plate thus cracking the vinyl. (see photo) Take care to file the shortened plate edge down and I put a couple layers of gray fabric tape along the edge to insure that the cushions were not cut by a sharp edge.
    My flight durations are now only ruled by fuel capacity and not comfort. Because I can sit lower and nestle into my little butt pocket, my legs are allowed to be straightened out more, lowering the knees and making for generally much enhanced comfort. I can honestly say that I have NO sore butt or tail bone problems at all! I can fly two hours with perfect comfort.
    If you want to get more professional, one could use webbing such as the lawn chair type which could be riveted to the shortened plate and wrapped around the back tube. For now, my wire ties work perfectly and flying my Challenger has no comfort distractions.
    This modification cost virtually nothing and took about an hour to complete considering I already had the aluminum seat and back. If you have the canvass seat, you will need to make up a seat back and half plate for seat, which will take you longer. Either way, it is not an ordeal…but the payoff of well worth it! Ahhhhhh!
    Because I have an ample posterior, I also made another modification to the rudder pedals for the rear seat. I cut them off diagonally, rivited a small tube along the edge so there was no sharp edge thus they no longer rub against my legs. (See Photo)

abarnard4.jpg (89413 bytes)abarnard3.jpg (63656 bytes)

Auxiliary Fuel Tank PHOTOS:

abarnard5.jpg (27181 bytes)abarnard6.jpg (22548 bytes)abarnard7.jpg (17079 bytes)abarnard8.jpg (23297 bytes)abarnard9.jpg (16250 bytes)

1.  The aux. tank placed in airplane
2.  A straight on shot of facet pump mounted
3.  A side view of facet pump mount
4.  The outlet valve and the 2X4 spacers glued to the bottom of tank to
protect the outlet valve.
5.  How I drilled my tank cap and installed hose and quick disconnect.

Jim Duke's diagrams with a little enhancement for clarity:
abarnard10.jpg (50692 bytes)abarnard11.jpg (72274 bytes)
1.  Front View
2.  Side View

I basically followed Jim's layout.  I  added the 2X4's and the fuel cap hose entry as my own ideas. Needless to say...so I'll say it..I neither recommend nor endorse this approach to aux. fuel to anyone.  It was my choice to use it as it will be others and they should satisfy themselves with regard to any and all issues connected with this approach.  It is only what I did.
    It works really slick.  My facet pump pumps 1/2 gallon a minute.  If you use a faster one, I think you will need to be sure that the air will displace as fast as the fuel goes in.  

582 Installation

582-1.jpg (24156 bytes)582-2.jpg (22460 bytes)582-3.jpg (24087 bytes)582left-3.jpg (73439 bytes)582lft-5.jpg (60580 bytes)582rht-6.jpg (62288 bytes)582lft-9.jpg (35676 bytes)582radtr-7.jpg (33211 bytes)582rdtrF-8.jpg (21884 bytes)

My design of Stabilizer Fins

I have my second Challenger II, and fly frequently with the doors on.  In that configuration, I too have found that the yaw axis “wallows” rather responds to my input.  I felt I could live with it until I had a reason to practice slips.  Ugh!  I decided then that I wanted more predictability and response to the rudder with doors on and set about to solve the problem.

I read an article in the ICOA newsletter describing stabilizer fins which sounded interesting.  I also reviewed the recommended fins from Quad City.  What I did not like though, was the appearance.  A painted wood fin looked very much like an afterthought and did not do much for the lines of the airplane.  I wanted effectiveness with a clean appearance.  I also noticed that the recommended dimensions in the article were larger than those recommended from Quad City raising the question of what is the right size?

The material  I decided on was 3/16” clear Plexiglas which was from a distance, not even noticeable.  You have to walk up to the airplane before you even see them.  I used  3/16” which seemed to be strong enough yet not too heavy.  One could also choose other colors of Plexiglas which could compliment the paint scheme of the airplane if you wished.

I then elicited the help of Don Gillette, another Challenger owner in Sequim, near where I live.  We very carefully and scientifically determined the correct size.  We found some scraps at another friends shop that he had laying around and used the largest scraps he had! (His name is Don James, who quite literally has a stash of airplane stuff that would make Boeing blush.  What’s more, he is a bachelor who has his priorities straight.  His home consists of a shop that would be the envy of Mr. Wizard, a hanger with his Kolb under construction who’s floor you could eat off, and living quarters big enough for a refrigerator for beer, a TV, and a bed, none of which interferes with the tools and flow of his hobbies!)

So, having determined the correct size (only size we had..) we found some 1” x 1” x 1/8” 6061 extruded aluminum angle.  We had just enough that we could get four, 10” pieces...so that cinched that dimension.  We cut everything out, rounded the corners and installed them.  We used three bolts, size 3/16” x  5/8” #10 in each angle piece, spaced them for the bar size of the vertical stabilizer and bolted them up. 

We then slipped the angles onto the stabilizer and drilled 4 holes in each and put in 1/8” stainless steel pop rivets, measuring to be sure the fins were exactly perpendicular to the stabilizer.  That’s it!  All scrap parts, a couple of hours work and then it was time to fly the airplane and see how they work.

In a word....GREAT!  Good rudder response, no wandering left and right in level cruise and banking nearly as stable as with the doors off!  Oh yea...the nearly normal aspects of a slip returned.

 stab1.jpg (32607 bytes)stab2.jpg (34633 bytes)stab3.jpg (24360 bytes)stab4.jpg (30503 bytes)winglets.jpg (21638 bytes)

E-mail Alan

Up ] J.D. Stewart ] Chan Shippy ] Jim Hayward ] Brad Stiefvater ] Aaron Hollingsworth ] [ Alan Barnard ] Allen Mader ] Alvin Melton ] Art Freeman ] Bill Acker ] Bill Duerig ] Bill McFarland ] Bill Nicholson ] Bill Volcko ] Bob Lewis ] Bob McAdams ] Bob McDonald ] Bob Robertson ] Bob Snyder ] Bob Widmer ] Bryan Dunkin ] Bruce Kinman ] Carmel Roy ] Charles Thie ] Chick Torbett ] Claude Roy ] Collin Mooney ] Cory Wimpfheimer ] Curt Heggemeyer ] Curtis Watkins ] Dan Druen ] Dan Lindey ] Dan Wroe ] Daniel Levi ] Danny Tyre ] Darrel Richards ] Darren Blakley ] Darren Dodge ] Dave Cobb ] Dave Morrow ] Dave Stephens ] David Cecil ] Dick Purdue ] Dick Schneider ] Don Sampson ] Don Smith ] Don Varty ] Don Zank ] Don Witt ] Doug Boyd ] Doug Hempstead ] Doug Reams ] Doug Rueth ] Doug White ] Duane Bessler ] Ed Bradley ] Ed Hanley ] Ed Hughes ] Ellery Batchelder ] Ephraim Carter ] Eugene Devarenne ] Frank Beagle ] Frank Mills ] Frederick Kuester ] Fred Ramoni ] Gary Freitag ] Gary Holtz ] Gary Jones ] Gary Middleton ] George Pettit ] Gerd Wirickx ] Glen Freeman ] Grant Corlett ] Greg Perkins ] Greg Walls ] Guillermo Escutia ] Hal Hayden ] Hank Dasse ] Henry Wortman ] Irshad A Qureshi ] Jacques Leblanc ] James Breland ] James Eddy ] Jason Green ] Jay Dewberry ] Jay Faubion ] Jean Harvey ] Jeremy Casey ] Jerry Bartlesen ] Jerry Deckard ] Jerry Lee ] JG Hunter ] Jim Hodges ] Jim Duke ] Jim Hamilton ] Jim Hope ] Jim Lartin-Drake ] Jim Lewellyn ] Jim Reed ] Jim Robinson ] Jim Showker ] Jimmy Strickland ] John Barnes ] John Davis ] John Heagy ] John Kossup ] John Leidenheimer ] John Talbert ] Jon Ritter ] Jules Glogovcsan ] Ken Braddock ] Ken Ewald ] Ken Swasas ] Ken Taylor ] Kenneth Hart ] Kevin Lee ] Kurt Kingston ] Larry Davis ] Larry Gerek ] Larry Maner ] Larry Whittaker ] Leon Garrett ] Les MacLean ] Lew Pinkham ] Lloyd Reeves ] Louis Pouliot ] Manfred Gottschalch ] Mark Curtiss ] Mark Huntley ] Mark Ingum ] Mark Reagan ] Mark Starling ] Martin Perez ] Matt Anderson ] Michael Bourget ] Michael Brown ] Michel Bueffe ] Mike Baker ] Mike Dix ] Mike Harrison ] Mike Johnson ] Mike Pfeifer ] Mike Stephens ] Nick Savener ] Normand Daigle ] Paul Stepp ] Paul Tuttle ] Paul Wilcox ] Phil Baker ] Phil Trivilino ] Ray Baeza ] Ray Olson ] Ray Rosekrans ] Raymond Hanover ] Raymond Nash ] Red Stokes ] Richard Paquet ] Richard Parsons ] Richard Strauss ] Rick Marshall ] Rick Watson ] Rob Schonk ] Robert Harris ] Robert Sanner ] Ron Beasley ] Ron Henke ] Ron Liberty ] Ron Munro ] Ronnie Wren ] Russ Hauser ] Russell Calhoun ] Sam Davis ] Sam Williams ] Scott Milton ] Scott Smyth ] Sean Mercer ] Steve Bounds ] Steve Busby ] Steve Falk ] Steve Valk ] Steve Kuchera ] Steve Madgic ] Terry Boshom ] Terry Savage ] Thomas Jablonski Blackstone ] Thomas Marson ] Tim Bogenhagen ] Tim Campbell ] Tim Devorak ] Tim Egan ] Todd Balsimo ] Tom Compton ] Tom Sjoblom ] Tom Stone ] Wayne Silvan ] Wayne Waddel ] William Rutter ]